Research

No clear winner: Why packaging economics go beyond material cost in Europe

18 November 2026 12:00 RaboResearch

Packaging material selection is becoming a more strategic decision. Cost is important, but so are other factors.

Intro

Packaging material selection is becoming a more strategic decision. Material and conversion costs remain important, but they increasingly need to be considered alongside logistics, regulatory exposure, access to recycled feedstocks, and supply-chain resilience. This report examines rigid polyethylene terephthalate (PET), aluminum, and glass across four dimensions of competitiveness: market exposure, economics, regulatory and circularity readiness, and resilience to changing operating conditions.

PET, aluminum, and glass each offer distinct advantages, but their competitiveness is shaped by different combinations of cost, regulation, recycling economics, and supply-chain exposure. PET benefits from low weight and logistics efficiency but depends on access to cost-effective recycled content. Aluminum combines lightweight packaging with strong recycling economics, but remains sensitive to energy prices, commodity markets, and import dependence. Finally, glass benefits from abundant raw materials, high recyclability, and compatibility with reuse systems, but energy-intensive production and higher transport requirements can limit competitiveness.

No packaging material is inherently superior – their competitiveness depends on specific conditions. PET remains difficult to beat when cost efficiency, logistics, and lower transport emissions are the primary considerations. Aluminum benefits from its high scrap value and strong recycling economics, while glass can offer advantages where reuse systems are established and transport distances are limited.

The key question for producers is therefore no longer which material is cheapest today, but which material remains competitive under future regulatory, supply chain, and market conditions. As extended producer responsibility (EPR) fees, recycled-content requirements, carbon costs, and resource security become more important, material selection increasingly becomes a strategic business decision rather than a procurement exercise.

Disclaimer

The information and opinions contained in this document are indicative and for discussion purposes only. No rights may be derived from any transactions described and/or commercial ideas contained in this document. This document is for information purposes only and is not, and should not be construed as, an offer, invitation or recommendation. Read more